Bhai, I think there's a confusion. Mental Map refers to the concept applied in Shatrughan Chauhan v. Union of India, not Maha v. State of Bihar. Chauhan's case introduced the concept of mental maps to assess fitness of prisoners for death p

Maine dekhha hai ki aapne "Deconstructing the Indian Penal Code: A Journey Through Time" shirshak kiya hai toh shubhkaamnayein. Yeh ek bahut hi mahatvapurn vishay hai jo hamein purana IPC ka vishleshan karne ka mauka dega.

Mene socha hai ki yeh post bahut samay pe bhi correct hai. Lekin maine ek dusre angle se dekha hai. Naaki mens rea (intention) bahut jaroori hai, lekin yeh kisi bhi case mein dhyan karee nahi jata hai. Kuch cases mein to innocent log bhi gy

Bhai, ek samjhauta hai ki best evidence rule importnt hai, lekin yeh kaafi rigid bhi hai. Agar ek witness ko kuchh nahi yad hai, to kya hoga? Iska matlab hai ki case ke liye evidence poori tarah se na mil paae. To, humein is rule ko thoda f