Distinction between 'Constructive Dismissal' and 'Retrospective Effect of Resignation'
labour clat_pg beginner doubtMaine CLAT PG k preparation ki thi aur mujhe yeh do concepts bilkul confused kardiye hain. Maine socha, kya aap log bhi pata chaleinge? Constructive Dismissal, Resignation aur Retrospective Effect of Resignation yeh saare cheezein ek dusre se judi hui hain. Pehle to hum log jaante hain ki jab employee ko company ne tenure se bina notice diya ke job se nikala hai, toh vah constructive dismissal ka maamla hai. Lekin, yeh bhi aata hai ki jab employee ne resignation di hai, iska effect retrospective ho sakta hai. To, kya voh bhi kuch samajhe?
5 Comments
Hello friends, Constructive Dismissal aur Retrospective Effect of Resignation ka difference kya hai? Constructive Dismissal woh condition hai jahan employee ko workplace mein aisa feel karta hai jaise usko fir se koi job nahin karne ka mauka doosra. Retrospective Effect voh case hai jab employee ka resignation pehle se signed ho jata hai, lekin uska effect abhi tak kuch din baad hi milta hai.
Yar, constructive dismissal aur retrospective effect of resignation ke beech ka farak bahut jyada hai. Jab koi officer apne kaaryalay ke saath sahi vichar nahi rakh rahe hai, yeh constructive dismissal hota hai. Lekin jab koi officer apne resignation ki pahli date se pehle hi office se chhut gaya hai, toh yeh retrospective effect hota hai. Dono hi situation kanooni tareeke se handle honi chahiye.
"Aapki kya zaroorat hai? In dono concepts ki wajah se aapko job se hataya ja sakte hai. 'Constructive Dismissal' hai jab employer job ki shartiyon ko badal dete hai ya aapko apne hisaab se job se hatane ke liye majboor karte hain. Jab ki 'Retrospective Effect of Resignation' hai jab aap apni istifa ke baad pata chala ke job ki shrtiyon badal deti hain.
Yaar, constructive dismissal hai when employee feels forced to quit due to intolerable work conditions or breach of contract. Retrospective effect of resignation, on the other hand, refers to when resignation takes effect from a past date. Not the same thing. Constructive dismissal is about termination of contract, while retrospective effect is about when the resignation kick in. Koi difference, yaar!
"Abhi to mere pas ek confusion hai, kya constructive dismissal aur retrospective effect of resignation dono hi ek hi thing hain? But agar dekha jaye, constructive dismissal jo ki employer ki kharabi kareeb hone par employee ko resignation dene par majboor karta hai, usme employee ki resignation ke baad hi employer ke actions ka impact hota hai. Retrospective effect of resignation pehle hi resign karein aur phir hi employee ko kuch nuksan pahunchane ki koshish karega.