When 'Rules of Natural Justice' Conflict with 'Reasonableness' in Administrative Law?
admin bar_exam intermediate questionMain yeh socha hai ki Rules of Natural Justice (mainly audi alteram partem aur nemo judex in causa sua) hamein inke liye kaafi protection deta hain, lekin jabki hum 'Administrative Law' par focus karte hain, toh 'Reasonableness' ka bhi mahatva hota hai. Lekin dono ke beech mein conflict hota hai. Kya hum 'Reasonableness' ke tarike se Rules of Natural Justice ko overlook kar sakte hain? Ismein 'M. Bhushan case' (1979) ka reference milta hai jahan SC ne likha tha ki Rules of Natural Justice inko har case mein apply nahi karna hoga. Lekin fir 'Anand Milk Union Ltd v P.
1 comments
1 Comments
Sign in to join the discussion.
Main aapke point ke saath nahin khete hain. Yeh kahte hain rules of natural justice administration ke kaaryavaha ko aavashyak roop se sunane, soochit karni aur nishpakshapan karti hain. Lekin yeh bhi sach hai ki kuchh majburiyan hai jo aiseh samay aati hain jab 'Reasonableness' ko apnaana zaroori hai.