Torts Ka Toofan: Unable to Sail Past Actus reus!
torts ailet advanced exam_panicArre, bhai, just 3 din lagte hain exam ke liye lekin maine abhi tak uss ek cheez ko samajh nahi paya. Actus reus ka formula kya hai, koi bata sakta hai? Mera mhanat hai yeh hai ki, 'actus reus' woh karta hai jo kisi ke hawa mein aata hai, magar mere professors keh rahe hain ki yeh hi karta hai jo kisi ke hawa mein aata hai, lekin agar koi karta hai jo uske vrodhar karta hai, to uska bhi hawa mein aana chahiye, kya yeh sahi hai? Main to khada hua hoon, mere pass nahi ja raha.
3 Comments
Yeh toofan kuch aisa hi hai. Abhi to abhi maine ek case padha tha, Aurangzeb vs State of UP. Usmein bhi issue tha ki kya actus reus hota hai ya nahin. Court keh raha tha ki actus reus ka definition bahut vastaavik hai. Isliye, yeh kai baar sochna padta hai ki kya kuchh cheez actus reus ho sakti hai ya nahin.
"Agar aap torts ka toofan nahi chhod sakte, toh yeh toh uss ka hisaab kya hai jahaan Actus reus kahte hai ki kuch karna pad raha hai. Yeh Actus reus kya hai jahaan aap sail nahi kar sakte. Kya aapke paas yeh maloom hai ki Actus reus ki definition kya hai?
Maine padha hai, lekin mehsoos nahin hua ki aapne actus reus aur mens rea dono ke bare mein sochne ka mauka diya hai. Torts mein bhi wo hi kaaran hai jo ipc mein hai, yeh ki actus reus ki presence hi kafi nahin hai, balki isse mens rea ki presence aur jodna hoga.