Tort Liability: A Hiccup in Private Defence
torts clat_ug beginner mcq_helpMaine ye question 3 baar padha aur abhi bhi samajh nahi aaya 😭. Dekho:
X attacks Y's wife in a fit of rage. Y chases X on his motorbike and injures him while trying to stop him. X sues Y for damages. Decide:
A) Y is liable for trespass to the person B) Y is liable for private defence C) Y is liable for assault D) X had given consent to Y to chase him and hence Y is not liable
Meri galat koshish: B) Y is liable for private defence (lagta nahi ki maine private defence seekha 😴). Ab toh mere saath batao, sahi kya hai?
4 Comments
Hello friends, I think the concept of tort liability in cases of private defence is quite tricky. While private defence is a lawful action, any excessive force used can lead to tort liability. For instance, 'Nanheji vs State of Maharashtra' (2015) held that private defence can't be used as a shield to avoid tort liability. So, it's a delicate balance between right to life and right to bodily security.
"Bhai, Tort Liability aur Private Defence ke beech ka sawal kaafi tricky hai. Jab koi individual apne defence ke liye kuch bhi kare, toh usmein wo tort liability ka hissa nahi hona chahiye. Lekin, agar wo defence me se koi action ke liye zaruri ho toh, wo tort liability ke under aayegi, jab tak uska koi vaidh authority nahi hoti.
Bhaiye, Tort Liability aur Private Defence ka ye topic bohot ruchiyan hai. Agar aapka manana hai ki private defence ke under action take kiya ja sakta hai, to kya tort liability ko aage se rokne ka yeh ek achha tareeka hai? Main aaplog ke saath yeh saamne mein raha hoon ki private defence ke cases mein tort liability ke rules ka pura paalan hota hai ya nahi? Share kijiye aapki rai!
"Tort Liability: A Hiccup in Private Defence" ke topic par aap sabhi ka shubhkamnayein!! Main aapse ek sawal uthne jaunga, kya koi hamare dushmanon ko gher mein pahunchne ki koshish kar rahe hain phir bhi, private defence ke liye tort liability kya hai? Ye sawal sochne ka koi aisa avsar nhi hai jismein hum apne kanoon ke bare mein soche!!