The Unreliability of Section 84 Plea in Indian Courts
criminal cuet_pg beginner discussionArre, guys, Section 84 plea ke baare mein aap logon ke paas kya vichaar hain? Ye Section IPC's Section 84 hai, jo mental ability ke beech aavaran wale shasana ko protect karte hai. Lekin mujhe lagta hai ki ye Section 84 plea, kabhi kabhi Indian courts mein koi bhi affect nahi karti.
Aapne kuch cases dekhne hain, jaise ki Ritesh Gupta vs. the State of UP (2010). Is case mein, accused ke liye Section 84 plea rakha gaya tha, lekin court ne isko reject kar diya.
2 comments
2 Comments
Sign in to join the discussion.
Section 84 plea kuch hai aur kuch nahi, but reality hai ki yeh kai baar misuse hota hai. Yeh shayad kyonki yeh madhyam keval un par lagayega jo jaanwaron jaisa hai, mental chalta hai. Lekin yeh unke liye bhi ek defense ban sakta hai jo mental health se jude muddo ke liye.
Arre, yaar! Section 84 plea toh bahut controversies wala matter hai. Yeh to bahut vague definition hai, jisse high court toh low court dono se juda case bhi aata hai. Sabse bada problem yeh hai ki yeh plea kisi bhi court mein accept ho sakta hai, aur yeh koi solid evidence ki zarurat nahin hai. Isliye, yeh to aam taur par koi reliable defense ni hai.