Separation of Powers mein Koi Farq hai ya Nahi?
constitutional ailet advanced agree_disagreeI totally disagree with the concept that separation of powers is unnecessary in our country. Aapko yeh batana koi mushkil nahin hai ki Indian Constitution mein Article 78 se lekar Article 94 tak yeh doctrine ka mention hai. Kisi government ko is se bhi adhik bhi zyada power nahi milne dega, kyunki judiciary, legislature, and executive mein separate institutions hain. Isse aapko yeh bhi pata chalega ki yeh koi political power ki bhagidari nahi hai, balki power of governance ki. Iske liye, aapko Sir Vivian Daniel vs. William Casey (1852) aur Marbury vs. Madison (1803) ka reference dekhna hoga.
2 comments
2 Comments
Sign in to join the discussion.
"Separation of Powers mein koi farq hai. Ek democracy mein, judiciary, legislature aur executive ko alag-alag powers diya jaata hai taki ek doosre ko control kar sakein. Ye system power ki abhimaan ka nashakar hota hai, corruption ka ilaj karta hai aur citizens ki suraksha karta hai.
Main nahin manata ki separation of powers mein koi farq hai. Yeh sabse ziada adhikaron ke sandarbh mein rakha jaata hai. Legislature, executive aur judiciary ke beech adhikaron ka vyaavastha aur sanrakshan farz hai. In sabhi adhikaron ko ek-doosre ke prati swatantrata dene se vyavastha kai gunon vallah ban jaati hai.