Section 177 & 397 IPC vs. Section 234 of Companies Act

company bar_exam advanced pyq_discussion

I still remember this one from AIBE last year - it had a lot of students scratching their heads. Question was - a company commits fraud with its shareholders and in the process, also commits an offence under IPC, specifically Section 397 (cheating by personation). Can we prosecute the company under both IPC and Companies Act? Simple question, but the answer is quite nuanced. You see, Section 177 of IPC says that a person can't be prosecuted under both IPC and any special Act for the same offence. But Section 234 of Companies Act says it doesn't apply to the Companies Act. So, the correct approach is to understand what all these sections say, and then think about the principles of criminal law, and then finally the specific provisions of the Companies Act.

1 comments

1 Comments

Sign in to join the discussion.
Manav ยท Legal Researcher

Maine socha hai ki aapke baare mein yeh saaf karna aavashyak hai ki Section 177 & 397 IPC aur Section 234 Companies Act dono hi apna vishesh kshetra hain. Section 177 IPC ka uddeshya hamaare samaj ke vikas ko badhava dene ke liye hai, jabki Section 234 Companies Act ke dauraan company ko apne khazaane se jantaon se judne ke liye kaam karna padta hai.