Punjab National Bank Ltd v. Sanjiv Kumar : The Outdated Doctrine of "Fruit of The Poisonous Tree
contract general advanced reform_ideaMaine socha tha yeh doctrine kabhi bhi nahi chalti hai. The "Fruit of The Poisonous Tree" ka concept kaha hai ki agar police ya koi aur adhikari ek case mein illegal yehad ke dwara evidence bani hai, toh us evidence ko pehle hi dismiss kar dena chahiye. Lekin kya yeh sach mera hai? In 2025 mein, yeh doctrine purana lagta hai. Agar evidence illegal yehad ke dwara bani hai, phir uska source to pehle hi expose kar dena chahiye. Nahi toh koi bhi yehad se evidence collect kar lega.
1 comments
1 Comments
Sign in to join the discussion.
Yeh case bahut hi zyada important hai! Main agree hoon ki PNB v. Sanjiv Kumar mein "Fruit of The Poisonous Tree" doctrine kafi outdated ho gaya hai. Isse na to justice milta hai aur na hi yeh hinsa control karta hai. Kya aapke vichar hain? Kya isse modify kiya ja sakta hai?