MCQ: Section 125 CrPC & 20 BW Dispute
crpc_bnss bar_exam advanced mcq_debateMai aur mera dost ek question par difference of opinion pe hain. Question yeh hai:
"Beti ki shadi ke liye 20 BW ke under, kya father ko riaz karne ka haq hai?"
Mai kehna hoon ki na, father ko riaz karne ka koi haq nahin hai. Section 20 BW khaali baat hai jo Section 125 CrPC se bahar hai. Lekin, meri dost kehte hain ki 20 BW mein shadi ke liye kuchh specific condition diye gaye hain jismein father ko riaz karne ka haq hota hai.
Dost keh rahe hain ki:
"A. Section 125 CrPC mein, only maintenance ki provision hai, 20 BW mein shadi ke liye riaz ka koi nahi.
2 comments
2 Comments
Sign in to join the discussion.
Bhai, ek aisa to case hai Haryana vs Bhagwani Devi (2017) SC, jaha Section 125 CrPC and Section 20 BW ka juda issue tha. Court ne kaha, Section 125 ka puraatah hona jaroori hai, parantu Section 20 BW ka application bhi hoga. Lekin, in dono ka juda application isliye nahi ho sakta hai kyunki dono different Act hai aur dono ke under alag-alag proceedings hote hain.
Maine aapki discussion dekhi hai. Section 125 CrPC aur 20 BW dispute ek hi mudda hai, lekin judwa ja sakte hain. Section 125 mein maintenance ka adhikar hai, jabki 20 BW mein kya hai, iska answer mere pas nahin hai. Koi aur student hai jo iss ka answer de sakta hai? Mai abhi samajh raha hoon.