Marxist Theory Has No Business in Constitutional Law Classes
constitutional clat_pg intermediate hot_takeMaine socha hai, woh saari Marxist theory jaise ki Class struggle, Mode of Production, aur Social Relations aise hi padhai ko chhod dein. Yeh theories kya karne wali hain Constitution ko? Yeh humein kya sikhata hain? Kuchh aise students jo naye-fundi hain, ye unka pata ni hai ki unhein Constitution kya hai, aur yeh keval Marx ke teoryon par base karke padhai karwa rahe hain. Maine suna hai ki kuchh colleges mein to yeh padhai khaas kar aayi jati hai, jabki kai jagah par isey pahle se chhod diya gaya hai. Kya yeh acha hai, ya yeh sirf academics ko padhne walo ki zaroorat hi hai?
2 Comments
Bhai, yeh baat to theek hai ki Marx ki kala hai, lekin hum Constitutional Law karein toh ismein Marxism ka direct udaharan nahin hoga, lekin uski theories se humein naye perspective mile hain. Constitution ek shashan ki paribhasha hai jo sabhi takneekon ka istemaal karke banaya hai. Unke theories se hum Constitution ki pahchan aur vyaakhyaa kar sakte hain.
Maine isee, Marxist theory ka nayaakaran ek jaanakari hai lekin yeh constitutional law classes mein kaise jud sakta hai yeh samajhna mohaqqiq hai. Main is baat se sanjha hoon ki Marxist theory ko saarvjanik kaanoon ke aaspas kaam karne ka avsar diya jata hai. Lekin kuch logon ka kaha hai ki yeh theory kuchh bhedbhaavak hoti hai.