Last Day ka Hissa: BSA & Evidence Act mein Hamesha ka Problem
evidence du_llb beginner late_night_postAbhi to mujhe lagta hai kya main gyaanwar hoon, par kuchh aisa hai jo mere dimaag mein khatam ho gaya tha - "A person is said to be of unsound mind, if at the time of committing a thing, he by reason of lunacy or insanity was incapable of knowing the nature of the act, or if he knew it, that he did not know he was doing what was either wrong or contrary to law." (Sec 84 IPC). Kya yah BSA 1953 ke Evidence Act ke andar aata hai ya Direct IPC? Aur yadi BSA mein mention hi nahi kiya hai, tab kya karen? Ye sab questions mere dimaag se kuchh hour se pehle hi chale gaye the par abhi tak main confused rehti hoon!
7 Comments
I respectfully disagree. While BSA ka last day clause bahut confusing lagta hai, evidence act ke principles ko isse hamesha problem nahi banana chahiye.
Bhai, ye โLast Dayโ ka hissa BSA aur Evidence Act dono me hi kaafi
Beta, BSA aur Evidence Act ka yeh "clash" exam hall mein sabse bada trap hai! Basic problem yeh hai ki BSA ek special law hai, lekin jo din maine padha tha wahan clear provision tha ki kahan tak Evidence Act apply hoga aur kahan BSA ki apni rules kaam karengi. Students aksar general evidence rules ka reference dete hain, jo technically galat hai. So, next time jab yeh topic aaye, pehle section confirm karo.
Arre bhai, BSA ki "savings" aur Evidence Act ke burden of proof... yeah, itโs a combo that hits hard. ๐คฏ But listen, last day is for revision, not panic. Just skim the leading cases; donโt try to memorize every word. Trust your last-minute intuition. Youโve survived two years of this torture already, so one final push wonโt break you. Kya kar rahe ho? Keep your chai hot and your brain sharper. You got this! ๐ช๐
Bhai, totally agree. Evidence Act mein sections yaad rakhna toh ho sakta hai, lekin BSA ki practicals + Evidence ke cross-examination tricks milate hi dimaag gaad ho jaata hai. Last day pe dono mix mat karna. pehle Evidence ke 30-40 core sections revise karo, phir bas BSA ki critical provisions par focus. Ratta nahi, logic use karna. All the best!
Bhai, totally agree. BSA ki "official knowledge" aur Evidence Act ke Section 46/31 ka clash exam mein trap bana deta hai. Judges ko lagta hai evidence is irrefutable, but legally ab evidence is evidence, it needs corroboration. Don't just trust the police diary blindly. Practice question mein kabhi kabhi yahi point negative marking ka reason banta hai, so be precise with the legal basis. Stay sharp, don't get fooled by the "final day" pressure.
Bhai, totally agree! Section 167 ka "magical" extension aur Evidence Act ka hearsay rule humara naubat hamesha bana rehta hai. BSA mein last day ka deadline miss ho jaye to civil suit ban jaata hai, yeh pressure next level hai. Coursework se zyada practical pyaar chahiye is topic ko. Faltu mein tension mat lo, past papers padh lo, wahi key hai. All the best, future advocate!