Is the Right to Equality Really Equal?
constitutional ailet intermediate late_night_postMujhe lagta hai, koi bhi case likho, koi bhi Article 14 ka reference ho, judge ka jawab kya hota hai? "Aapki equality, mere bhai, mere woh bhi equality hai." Lekin kyaa, kya bhi ho, kuchh to kareeb 90% case mein Article 14 ka use ho jaata hai. Ismein se kuchh to right to equality ki wajah se dismissed, kuchh to khud ko right to equality ke adheer karke dismiss kare hain. Example hai, the landmark case of Olga Tellis vs. Bombay Municipal Corporation (1980). Ismein Article 14 ka use karke, Supreme Court ne pavement dwellers ko apne home ki shuruaat ki permission di thi.
4 Comments
Bahut accha sawal hai! "Is the Right to Equality Really Equal?" Aapne bahut sahi question kiya hai. Inka jawab aapko Article 14 mein dekhna hoga. Yeh article kaafi strong hai aur sabko equal rights guarantee karta hai. Lekin reham karte hain, yeh article ka implementation toh sirf paper pe hai. Aapko Article 14 ke andar kuchh case study karna chahiye. Woh aapko sachchai ka matlab padhega.
Additional-info: Equality ka concept, to sahi se samajne ke liye fundamental rights chapter mein padhna bahut zaroori hai. Samata adhikar ka ek mahatvapoorn ang hai, lekin kya vahi hamesha same raha hai? Kuch kanooni shikayatein aur judgements padhne se pata chalega ki samata adhikar kaise vyavastha mein kaam karta hai aur kis tarah se iska upyog kiya jata hai.
Bhai log, right to equality is a fundamental right, par kuch issues hain. Like, Article 14 says equality before law, but it doesn't guarantee equal opportunities. Aur Article 15 says no discrimination on grounds of sex, caste, etc, but it's not always implemented. So, equality seems more like a theoretical concept than a reality on the ground. Kya log kya kehenge, but honestly, still a lot to be done.
Bhaiya, ek baat to sahi hai - Article 14 ki guarantee kuch aisa na ho jise Equality of Law kehte hai. Lekin, kya yeh sab jagah pe sahi hota hai? Aap hi dekhain, SC ko aise case milte hain jahan ek aadmi ne 'Equal Treatment' ka claim kiya, lekin unhein usi se alag treatment mila! Equality to nahi hota, aur sahi nahi hota.