Is Pre-Contractual Intermediary Negotiations Binding?
contract clat_ug intermediate mcq_debateMere dost aur main kuch hi ghante pehle discussion karte rahe the, aur yeh MCQ unhein pasand aaya hai. Kya aap bhi is par apne vichar dikhayenge?
Question: X agreed to sell Y a property for 10 lakhs in writing. During the negotiations, an intermediary (Z) assured Y orally that the property was worth only 8 lakhs. Y relied on this statement and agreed to buy the property for 9 lakhs. Is the oral assurance by Z binding on X?
Meri baat hai ki Y ne intermediary ki statement par vishwas kiya, kya X par bhi uska impact padega? Dost keh rahe hain ki X ke paas intermediary ka koi connection nahi hai, toh iska koi samay nahin hai.
2 Comments
Dost, pre-contractual intermediary negotiations kya binding hain ya ni? Supreme Court ne kaha hai, mere jaankari ke hisaab se, ki ye negotiations binding nahi hain, yadi aapko anya contract ya agreement ke under bind karna hai, toh aapko usme kuch specific terms mention karna hoga. Bina specific terms ki, ye simple conversation hi hai.
Arre bhai, don't worry, this topic ka confusion to bahut ho sakta hai. But, let me tell you, pre-contractual intermediary negotiations are not always binding, yaar. It depends on the intention of the parties, written agreements, and the concept of "pacta sunt servanda" (contracts must be kept). You can't force someone to do something if they never agreed to it, bas. Keep reading and researching, you'll get it, bhai.