Fundamental Right ke liye Judicial Review ki limit kya hai?

constitutional clat_ug advanced question

I toh confusion me hoon - maine read kiya ki Judicial Review Fundamental Rights ke liye zyada limit nahi rakh sakti hai kyunki yeh Parliament ke prerogative hai aur Constitution Amendment Act se sambhav hai. Lekin phir bhi SC ne Kesavananda Bharati ka case mein Parliament ki power ke sath saath Fundamental Rights ke peechhe hath rakha hai. To ab kya hai, Judicial Review ki limit kitni hai? Kya yeh only Constitutional amendments ke cases mein apply hota hai? Maine abhi till date koi clear explanation nahi find kiya hai. To aap bhaiyon, koi clarification kare.

3 comments

3 Comments

Sign in to join the discussion.
Aditya ยท Law Student

Bhai, actually Judicial Review is the very power to enforce Fundamental Rights under Article 32, so "limit" ka concept thoda alag hai. But remember, Parliament canโ€™t abrogate these rights. However, during National Emergency (Article 352), most FRs suspend ho jate hain, except Articles 20 and 21. Also, SC canโ€™t strike down a law if itโ€™s a valid preventive detention, just check its procedural validity. Simple hai, right?

Roshni ยท Law Student

Bhai, bilkul sahi point hai! Basic Structure Doctrine (Kesavananda Bharati case) ki wajah se, Court Fundamental Rights ko takleef nahi de sakti. Lekin yaad rakhna, Article 13 ke tehat sirf Constitution ke articles hi review ho sakte hain. Statutory laws ke liye Section 312 ka use nahi hota. Matlab, limits clear hain: structure aur essential elements untouchable hain. Isme koi doubt nahi!

Dhruv ยท Bar Exam Prep

Arre tension mat lo! Judicial Review fundamental rights pe fully apply hoti hai, lekin โ€œpolitical questionโ€ ya โ€œmilitary discretionโ€ jaise areas mein court thoda cautious rehta hai. Par yaad rakhna, Article 13 ka scope iska bhi badhta hai. Matlab limit fixed nahi hoti, context matter karta hai. MCQs solve karo case laws dekho, confidence aayega. Aap dekh lo, maine bhi yahi struggle kiya tha. Keep going, clear hoga!