Difference b/w O.P. Singh vs. State of U.P. and S.R. Bommai vs. Union of India
admin judiciary beginner questionMaine Administrative Law ka syllabus padha hai lekin main confuse ho gaya hoon. O.P. Singh vs. State of U.P. case mein kya hua tha? Koi decision toh nahi thi, bas hi mere pass hain kuch lines jo court case ko dismiss karne ke baare mein hain. Lekin S.R. Bommai vs. Union of India case mein toh sabse pahle court ne kiya kya tha? Veto power ka concept use kiya gaya tha. Maine socha ki O.P. Singh vs. U.P. case mein bhi kuch hi aisa hi hua hota, par aisi koi baat nahi hai. Maine koi article padha hai jisme likha hai ki O.P.
2 Comments
"O.P. Singh vs State of U.P aur S.R. Bommai vs Union of India me ek bahut bada farq hai. O.P. Singh me, O.P. Singh ke apne V.C.O. ki shapath lete samay, V.C.O. ne unki jald se jald svaayat karn ke liye apnay liye, jo saavdhaanee ki jaa sakti hai. Lekin S.R. Bommai vs Union of India me, C.M.
Bhai, clarification required hai. Yeh dono cases different topics pe hain. O.P. Singh ka case article 19 ke liye aaya, Article 20 ka mention nahin kiya. S.R. Bommai ka case article 356 ke interpretation ke liye aaya. Pehla case civil liberties ka discussion kiya, jabki S.R. Bommai ka case constitutional validity ka test kiya.