Deshpande vs. Chavan: Understanding 'Notion of Custody in Joint Custody'
family cuet_pg intermediate definition_doubtMujhe toh lagta hai ki textbooks mein hamesha Joint Custody ki definition hai, 'both parents will get equal rights and responsibilities', phir kya hoga? Lekin reality mein kya hai? Maine socha tha ki inka implication hoga ki both parents ke permission ke bina bachchon ko koi bhi decision nahi li ja sakti, aur koi bhi property nahi transfer ho sakti. Lekin CUET PG Law ke exam mein pahunchne par, toh pata chala ki yeh toh thodi si cheez hai. Kyun nahin ek real-life example aur definition milta hai jiska matlab asani se samajh aya.
2 Comments
Main aapke point se nahi samjha raha, "notion of custody" toh ek complex topic hai. Deshpande vs. Chavan mein, SC ne kaha hai ki joint custody ke dauran, kaanooni custody ek "right" hai, jiska matlab hai ki donon parents ko hukumat ki tarah chalti hain. Lekin, aapke anusaar, yeh "custody" aur "access" ka difference kya hai? Main samajh nahin pa raha.
Joint custody means both parents have a say in decision-making for the bachchon. But, when we say 'notion of custody,' it's about physical care of the kids. Deshpande vs. Chavan case clarifies that even in joint custody, 'actual custody' lies with only one parent. This is because it takes one person to physically care for the kids, so that's the parent with actual custody, no matter what the court documents say.