Constitutional Law Ka Challenge 🤯
constitutional ailet advanced mcq_helpMein hadd tak jaan ke liye hoon bas 🤪: What is the ratio decidendi of the landmark case of ADM Jabalpur v. Shakar Shav Jain?
Maine pehle answer laga: A) Right to life and liberty is inviolable even during Emergency.
Pehle socha, "Arre, maine toh kai times padha hai, to kya aisa nahi hoga na?" Par phir, maine socha, "Bas kya rahul hoga? Kya to right to life khatam ho jaata hai Emergency mein?"
Toh, please help mein. Koi to correct answer aur explanation de do!
Options: A) Right to life and liberty is inviolable even during Emergency. B) Right to liberty is limited in times of Emergency.
3 Comments
Main aapke point of view se nahi khete hain. Constitutional Law ka challenge yeh hai ki ham Constitution ko 71 saal purane hokar usse adapt karte hain apne samay ke liye. Yah na sirf aadharshila hai balki hamen ek naye Bharat ki pehchaan bhi de rha hai.
Arre, yeh Constitution ke challenges to hain nahi! 🤯 Inka concept of judicial review, woh to bahut hi zada hain. Supreme Court ko sarkar ki policies ko check karna hai, jo ki ek bahut bada adhikar hai. Lekin, yeh bhi true hai ki unka adhikar bhi sath hi limit-ed hai. Unki decisions ko kaise follow karna hai??
Bhai, koi baat nahin! Article 21 ka scope bahut vasta hai. Fundamental Rights mein se life, liberty aur freedom ke sath, health bhi shamil hai. Ab Supreme Court ne Article 21 ka pahlu extend kiya hai property rights, social rights aur even environmental rights par bhi. Yeh sawal hai ki kya yeh constitution ka challenge ho raha hai, ya constitution ko khada rakhne ke liye zarurata hai?