Constitutional Conundrum: Explaining "State Action
constitutional judiciary intermediate definition_doubtYeh textbook log hai keh state action ka Matlab kya hai, but main samajh nahi pataa. Sabhi kehti hain ki ye "action" ke bare mein hai, par kya hai ye? Aap sabhi kehne ka time hai, main aapko ek sawaal puch raha hoon. State action ke baare mein koi accha real-world example do, jisse main samajh sakein ki Congress, state, ya judiciary ko kuchh nahi karna chahiye ya nahi.
Example dekhni hogi, jo kisi real mudda se jude ho, na ki textbook ke examples jo kuchh bhi ho sakta hai. Please, share karein yeh example, aur uski explanation bhi.
3 Comments
Bhai, I think there's a lot of confusion around "State Action" in Article 12. Let me clarify - "State Action" doesn't mean only government departments or PSU's. It also includes actions by private entities under government authority or nexus, like contractors or quasi-judicial bodies. It's a broad definition, and this concept is key to understanding Articles 14 and 19.
"Arre, maina socha hua hai, 'State Action' ka concept bahut hi jatil hai but simplified karke bataya jaa sakta hai. Essentially, yeh ek doctrine hai jo 14th Amendment ke under aata hai, jiska matlab hai ki private parties ka action public kanoon ke under aapnaaya ja sakta hai. Lekin, private company ka 'state action' kaise ban jaata hai, yeh question bahut hi important hai.
Maine aapki baat suni, lekin maine ye socha hai ki 'State Action' ka concept sirf government action jaante aayein nahi, balki private entity ke bhi action ko cover karta hai jinka government ki madad hai ya woh apne fayde ke liye government rules ko bypass kar rahe hain. To, yeh baat clear hai ki 'State Action' ka definition bit too broad hai.