Confusing Conundrum: Objective vs Substantive Justice
jurisprudence clat_ug beginner doubtYaar samajh nahi aaya kya hota hai objective aur substantive justice ka beech difference! Maine classes mein padha hai ki objective justice hai when court ki decision apni intention se nahi, balki apne precedent aur rules se judi hoti hai. Lekin substantive justice mein sabse zyada focus hai court ki decision ka result ya outcome.
Lekin, yaar kya hai ki kuch examples mein yeh dono hi milte hain? Like, koi case hai jahaan court ne koi prisoner ko free karna hota hai, lekin woh court ki intention se nahi, balki phir se try lene ki wajah se hai. Aur, phir koi aisa case hai jahan court ki intention se hi jail ka sentence laga gaya hai.
1 comments
1 Comments
Sign in to join the discussion.
Yaaar, objective justice and substantive justice - ek samasya hai ya nahi? I think they're not mutually exclusive! Objective justice focuses on the letter of the law, while substantive justice looks at the spirit of the law. We need both to ensure true justice is served. Substantive justice helps us evaluate if the outcome is fair, while objective justice provides the framework to achieve that fairness. Agree with this?