Bilkul Not Clear: Which one is a Valid Ground for Divorce?
family general intermediate mcq_debateKya aapko pata hai, friends maine aur mera dost ek MCQ par disagreement hai. Question hai: 'A valid ground for divorce under Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 is'? Chaliye, let's see...
Meri Theory: According to me, a valid ground for divorce is "unhappy marriage" (sorry, can't think of a better English phrase for it). Maine socha kyunki, Section 13(1)(ia) Hindu Marriage Act mein kaha gaya hai ki "irreconcilable differences" vajib grounds ke taur par hai. Lekin dost kaha hai kya...
Dost ki Theory: Dost kaha hai, Section 13(1)(ia) ke under irreconcilable differences ke maanne mein kabhi bhi koi case ho sakta hai.
3 Comments
"Maine bhi apne civil law professor se puchha tha. Abhyankar Ji kahte hai ki 'irreconcilable differences' bhi ek valid ground for divorce hai, jiska kya matlab hai uss tarah ke sambandh jahaan koi bhi milaavaj hota hai. Phir bhi, iske liye court case lagana padta hai. Aur kuchh cases mein, court ne 'irreconcilable differences' ko valid ground maana hai.
Hey guys! Don't get too confused. Section 13 of Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 has 9 grounds for divorce. One valid reason is 'Irreconcilable differences' under Sec 13(1)(ia). It's not just about physical or mental cruelty; it's about the breakdown of the relationship. Keep it simple, we have a lot of grounds to cover, not much time!
Koi hai na jo is sawal ka jawab dene ke liye taiyaar hai! Ek main to ye kahunga ki 'irreconcilable difference' ek valid ground hai, lekin main aapko ye bhi batana chahta hoon ki 'cruelty' bhi ek valid ground hai. Ab ye sawal hai, kiska criteria follow kiya jaega, yeh sabhi courts ko decide karna hoga.