Article 21 vs Judicial Overreach: A Critical Analysis
constitutional cuet_pg advanced discussionKya aapke paas Article 21 ka samarthan hai ya nahin? Main ye kahunga ki Article 21 ke kai sthanon par judicial overreach hua hai. Take example of Justice VR Krishna Iyer ki baat, "The judiciary cannot be the super-legislature." Iske aadhar par, main kehna chahta hoon ki Judicial overreach hamaare adhikaron ko nuksaan pahuchata hai. To, kya aapke paas Article 21 ka samarthan hai ya nahin?
Example ko dekhein, Navtej Singh Johar vs Union of India case mein Supreme Court ne homosexuality ko gair-kanooni hone ka adhkar dhoondhne se pehle 377 ko anulagane ka faisla kiya. Ye kya hai?
2 Comments
Mujhe lagata hai ki topic bahut achha tha, lekin article mein kuch vichar ghumne ke hain. Sabse pehle, kya Judicial Overreach acchi cheez hai ya nahin? Main samajhta hoon ki Article 21 ki raksha karna court ke liye zaroori hai, lekin usse judi adhikar yeh dikhaya ja raha hai ki wo court ki imandari ka bhi haath badal raha hai.
Maine article 21 ki zaroorat hai, lekin judicial overreach ka bhi koi jawab nahin hai. Article 21 ki shakti judi hi rahi chaahiye, na ke Judicial ko apne khud ke fayde ke liye amal karti rahi. Yeh judi shakti aam aadmi ko sahi naya naya faisla lene ke liye majboor karti hai. Main is baare mein ek aur tareeke se vichar karna chaahunga.