Article 19(1)(a) aur Maa ka Doodh
constitutional ailet intermediate trick_questionAILET 2022, Q. 25: 'Article 19(1)(a) provides right to freedom of speech and expression. Can a private university impose a fine on a student for using abusive language in the hostel cafeteria?'
Aap logon ko lagta hai kya? Kaafi log thoda sa logical reasoning kaam karne ke baad, the correct answer deduce karta hai. Lekin main aapko warn karna chahta hoon - ismein trap hai. Sabse pehle, Article 19(1)(a) private university par kya kaam nahi karta. Ismein public ka concept hai. Lekin main problem yeh hai ki aapko sochna hoga ki is fine ki kya nature hai. Ismein criminal action ho rahi hai ya civil?
1 comments
1 Comments
Sign in to join the discussion.
"Main is baat se khuch nahin hoon. Article 19(1)(a) mein free speech ki guarantee hai lekin yeh koi anushasan nahin hai. Maa ka doodh toh ek aisi baat hai jo logon ke liye zaroori hai, lekin iske liye aapko public place mein pina nahin hoga. Yeh Article 19(1)(a) ke under aapko free speech nahin karna hai. Yeh dharna theek nahi lag rahi.