Admissible Evidence vs Hearsay - A Conundrum
evidence bar_exam intermediate poll_styleKya aapko lagta hai ki kya yeh dono statements evidence ke like hain ya nahin? Let's say case hai: A v. B
Statement 1: X nahi bolta ki A ne kuch kiya hai, balki Y bata raha hai ki X ne kuch kaha tha.
Statement 2: X nahi bolta, balki Y bata raha hai ki A ne kuch kiya hai.
Sabhi kehne wale, is baat ka naya hai ki Statement 1 hearsay hai kyunki X nahi bolta hai, aur Statement 2 direct evidence hai kyunki Y apne aapne aankhon se dekh raha hai. Lekin kya aapke pass pata hai ki yeh theek hai?
1 comments
1 Comments
Sign in to join the discussion.
"Admissible evidence vs hearsay - ek bahut hi chunautipurn dhang hai (a very challenging dilemma). Har kaam mein, kuch na kuch hearsay bhi aata hai, lekin yeh admissible nahin hai. Lekin, agar koi witnesses ke statement ki parwah karte hain toh yeh kaisa ho? Kya humein iska admissible evidence samajhna chahiye ya nahin? (In every case, some hearsay comes in, but it's not admissible.