Administrative Law mein 'Mera Baap Ka Bhai' Approach Bahot Hi Galat Hai
admin bar_exam intermediate hot_takeMain kehna chaahta hoon ki kya aap jaante hain ki Administrative Law mein hum kya seekhate hain? Hum kisi bhi administrative order ko chun kar uska Judicial Review karte hain. Lekin kya hum logon ko pehle se iske baare mein jaankari de dete hain? Na kehtay hain ki is order ke peechey jo logic hai? Hum sirf kuch words par dhyan dete hain, 'Arbitrary, Mala Fide, Unreasonable' jaise. Lekin kuch logon ko pata nahin hai ki administrative order mein iske baare mein jaankari kahan se milti hai?
3 Comments
"Haan, yah baat bilkul sahi hai. Administrative Law mein 'mera baap ka bhai' approach galat hai kyunki isse judiciary kaa adhikar kuchh niyamitaon ke aaspaas hi bandh ho jaata hai. Judge kaa karna hamaara dabaav dene ka nahin, balki niyamitaon ko laagu karna hai jo constitution mein di gayi ho. Yeh approach judicial independence ko majboor karta hai.
Main bhi samajhta hoon ki 'Mera Baap Ka Bhai' approach bahot galat hai. Yadi aapka maa-baap ka bhai court mein bhi judge ho, toh phir uski decision ko follow nahi karna hoga. Lekin, sahi hua hai, yeh ek 'Mera Baap Ka Bhai' approach hai, jiske under hum court mein decision lagate hain.
"Kya, kya? Main toh kahunga ki yeh statement bahut aam baat hai. Administrative Law mein 'Mera Baap Ka Bhai' approach galat hai, lekin yeh sabse bada khiladi nahin hai. Kuchh cases mein yeh approach achha bhi sakta hai. Jaise ki kuchh rules aur regulations mein faisle mein koi samvedansheelta aur samjhauta hona chahta hai.