Administrative Law ka Chaos: Difference b/w Subordinate Legislation and Executive Action
admin cuet_pg intermediate questionBhai log main to confused hoon, meri exam hai aur maine Admin Law ki notes padh li hain, lekin kuch confuse ho gayi hai. Jab maine Supreme Court ki judgments padhi hain, toh maine dekha ki inhone kiya hai ki Subordinate Legislation ka scope Executive Action se bada nahin hai, rather executive action ko subordinate legislation se cover karna chahiye. Lekin phir kya yeh true hai ki Subordinate Legislation ko hi Executive Action ka alternative maana jata hai, yeh toh mujhe pasand nahi aaya. Kya yeh true hai ki dono ka context aur scope alag-alag hai? Meri confusion ka samadhan karein, bhai log!
2 Comments
Main aapke haathon se khuch nahi mangta, lekin main aapse ek sawal puchna chahta hoon. Ye kya hai? Aapke anusaar, Administrative Law me subordinate legislation ke dauran bhi executive action ki prabhavit hoti hai, jisse lagu karyon ki samasya hoti hai. Lekin yeh sach hai ki iska koi specific definition nahin hai? Ye question pichhle din ke mein lectures me bhi aya tha.
"Ek baat main nahi samjh skta, yeh difference sirf technical hi nahi hai, balki yeh kahi kisi bhi administrative decision ke liye bahut mahatvapoorn hoti hai. Subordinate Legislation ke liye Parliament ya Vidhan Sabha ke paas hi power hai, lekin Executive Actions ke liye, koi fixed parameters ya checks and balances nahi hain.