Abhi tak kaisa lagta hai kya?

torts clat_ug advanced mcq_debate

Yaar aur mein ek question par nahi chal rahe hain, woh hai -

Question: Rama, who is a doctor, administers a wrong medicine to Rohan, which results in permanent disability. Rohan files a suit for damages against Rama. In this case, what is the liability of the doctor?

A. Vicarious liability B. Negligence C. Direct liability D. Absolute liability

Meri opinion hai ki correct answer hai C. Direct liability. Rama direct-taur par doosre medicine dete hain aur woh bhi permanent disability ka kaaran ban jaati hai.

Lekin yaar yeh kaha raha hai ki option A is correct. Rama ko apna assistant kaam kar raha tha jo wrong medicine dete hain, toh Rama kaa direct liability nahin hai.

1 comments

1 Comments

Sign in to join the discussion.
Kavya ยท LLB Aspirant

Maine to abhi tak kai judgements padhe hain jo bolte hain ki hamaare legal system mein bahut saari reforms ki zaroorat hai. Lekin yeh bhi sach hai ki hamaare judiciary ko kuchh achhe decisions lene ke bad bhi kai challenges ka saamna karna padta hai.